Using all we love about American Idol to create some writing guidelines came easier than we thought, though a slight caveat: we’re basing much of this on the original seasons with Simon, not the current season with Jennifer Lopez and Steven Tyler. No judgement.

On American Idol, wannabes are often slammed for trying to sing like their “idols.” Writers often make the same mistake. Your writing idols can be your muses, but at some point you’ll have to swim using your own voice, style, and perspective. Readers, like music aficionados don’t want imitations of what’s already out there.

2. Establishing a connection with your audience can make or break your career

Contestants on AI who connect with the audience, usually with their heartwarming background story and likable personality, become fast favorites. Authenticity is a key ingredient in building a relationship with any audience, readers especially.

3. Preparation, practice, and commitment keep you in the running

The singers (and we use this term loosely) that don’t make it past auditions are ones in denial about their level of skill. As a writer, a commitment to practice and learning the craft of writing earns you a spot in the next round.

4. Stay in your lane

Every singer is different and has their own unique tone. If a singer has a voice best suited for rhythm and blues, singing rock authentically is problematic. Everybody isn’t cut out to write historical novels, or vampire books. What’s your writing sweet spot? Once you know the areas where you’re the strongest, you’ll create better work.

5. Stand out from the crowd

The American idols that have won the coveted record deal, stand out from the crowd from the earliest episodes. Part of the appeal of American Idol is that viewers choose their “winner.” Think of your readers as an audience that you have to win over with your writing chops. Shaking it up and being original is the way to get your foot in with them.

6. Tell the truth

You could sum up Simon Cowell in one word: honest. His criticisms often come across as harsh and even insulting, but is admittedly part of his appeal. Some even label him refreshing. As a writer, seek true and unbiased feedback about your work. It’s a necessary leg in the journey of creating good writing. Also, as the voice behind your writing, tell the truth. As you create your work, share the most pure and true of its core.